The Mumbai gamble behind Mittansh Nithiyanandam’s MiLC record

Life has come full circle remarkably early for Mittansh Nithiyanandam. At 15, he needed special dispensation to become the youngest player to feature in Minor League Cricket. At 17, he became its youngest half-centurion. And on Saturday, barely a couple of years into adulthood, the 20-year-old completed the progression by becoming MiLC's youngest centurion, smashing 114 off 68 deliveries against a power-packed Chicago Kingsmen attack.

The symmetry was difficult to miss. Back in 2021, Nithiyanandam was an unknown 15-year-old playing a largely inconsequential practice match in Chicago when he walked in against a seasoned local bowler and deposited his first two deliveries for six. Watching from outside the boundary was Ashar Mehdi, then captain of the Chicago Blasters, who had never seen him before. Those two swings were enough to earn Nithiyanandam a closer look.

There was only one problem. Minor League Cricket required players to be at least 16. The Blasters were sufficiently convinced by what they had seen to submit a formal request seeking an exemption for Nithiyanandam which was approved later. What began with a teenager requiring special permission simply to enter the competition has, five years later, produced one of its youngest record-breakers.

The landmark carried an additional layer of emotion because Nithiyanandam had imagined this exact scene years earlier. During those early MiLC seasons, when he was mostly confined to the bench or buried down the order at No. 8, he would return home, pick up his bat and shadow-bat in front of a mirror, pretending he was opening the innings and scoring a hundred.

When the real hundred finally arrived, those images came flooding back. "I remembered those days when I was 15, 16 years old," Nithiyanandam said. "I would literally dream that one day I was able to do those things. When I hit the hundred and took my helmet off, I remembered those feelings. I knew that younger version of myself would be really, really proud."

Born in Mumbai before moving permanently to the United States when he was six months old, Nithiyanandam inherited the game from his father, a die-hard India supporter. They would wake at 4am for India matches and play together in the driveway until his father's frequent work travel made those sessions harder to sustain. Nithiyanandam then found his own solution. He would take stress-relief balls his mother brought home from work, throw them against the basement wall and bat for hours, turning couches into imaginary fielders.

That meant making a decision strikingly removed from the life unfolding around him. While many of his classmates were discussing dorm rooms, colleges and the traditional rituals of American campus life, conversations in the Nithiyanandam household revolved around Mumbai cricket clubs, training schedules and where he should live to make daily practice easier. He deferred college for a year and moved alone to Chembur in October 2024, committing himself almost entirely to cricket until the following April.

The opportunity came through his long-time coach Subu and the relationship between Chicago Youth Cricket Academy and Achievers Cricket Academy in Mumbai. What Subu could offer was access to the academy and an environment in which Nithiyanandam could train every day. There were no assurances, however, that any of Mumbai's fiercely competitive A Division clubs would actually pick him. It made the eight-month move something of a blind gamble. Nithiyanandam was willing to take it anyway, driven by little more than the conviction that immersing himself in Mumbai, the nursery of Indian cricket, would make him a better player. Getting into a team, and then staying there, would be entirely up to him.

It was a homecoming only in the technical sense. Mumbai was the city of his birth, but he had left it before he could remember it. Now, at 18, the Indian-American teenager was living alone in a Chembur apartment in a city that was culturally familiar yet practically foreign, having never previously been required to manage life entirely by himself.

He finally got a chance to audition with the DY Patil club and they liked what they saw during his initial sessions, but Nithiyanandam spent close to 15 games on the sidelines before an opening finally arrived. Even then, he squeezed into the XI at No. 7 as a bowling allrounder. Against the prestigious Cricket Club of India, he responded with 41 off roughly 30 deliveries, including four sixes, forcing his way into more regular opportunities.

Soon he wasn’t just playing Times Shield A Division cricket, but also the DY Patil T20 Cup which is considered one of the auditioning events of the IPL. The breakthrough into the league got him training alongside established professionals and sharing a dressing room with players such as Prasidh Krishna, Yash Dhull, Priyam Garg and Bhuvneshwar Kumar

“I learned a lot watching experienced players manipulate chases after early wickets. How red-soil pitches altered scoring options against spin. I developed the sweep and reverse sweep, shots that had never been central to my game in America. I began understanding when to attack, when to use the crease and how conditions should dictate decision-making.”

Yet Mumbai did not dilute the one characteristic that had defined him since those two sixes at 15. Fearlessness. Former India Under-19 captain and teammate, Garg, encouraged him not to lose it, even during four-day cricket. Nithiyanandam absorbed Mumbai's grind but retained the American instinct that had been forged on thick outfields where aerial hitting was often the most practical way to score.

That fusion was evident in his hundred against Kingsmen. The innings came only a day after an ignominious first-ball duck, trapped in front by a full toss he would expect to put away almost every time. Nithiyanandam went home, dissected the dismissal, spoke to his coach and arrived the next day determined not to allow one failure to alter his method.

Against a Kingsmen attack containing experienced professionals, including Ghulam Mudassar, who had clocked around 90mph during MLC, Nithiyanandam played with striking authority. Standing 6-foot-1, he used his long levers to launch seven sixes and eight fours. He was willing to advance against pace, manipulate his position inside the crease against spin and repeatedly sweep and reverse-sweep bowlers out of their preferred lengths.

Nearly 40 of his runs, came through the sweep variations painstakingly sharpened in Mumbai. It was perhaps the clearest evidence yet of what those eight months had added. The aggression remained but he had now added method to the madness that unfolds when he takes centrestage.

Nithiyanandam has already sacrificed much of what ordinarily defines an American teenage life. A varsity swimmer throughout high school, his days once began with 5am swimming practice, followed by school, another swim session, cricket training, homework and bed. He missed both proms and multiple homecomings because of tournaments. Serendipitously, he also scored a hundred on the same day as one of those proms.

Click here to read article